Got the Victoria’s Secret Eyeliner and used it last Friday. Been using it every since. I really liked it. Goes on smooth, lasts for most of the day. I’d be careful about putting it on the waterline of your eyes, by the end of the day it runs a little. You don’t look like a raccoon, but you also don’t have as neat of a line as you started with. To each’s own.
Would I buy it again? Probably not. I’m still on the search for America’s Next Top Eyeliner.